Guild icon
Superior Court of the State of Ridgeway
state-of-ridgeway-v-robloxgamer400253
Avatar
Ridgeway State CourtsBOT5/10/2022, 7:06:49 PM
State of Ridgeway v. robloxgamer400253
Case Information
Case Type
Criminal
Case Code
RSC-CM-351
Prosecution
State of Ridgeway
Defendant
robloxgamer400253
Avatar
Ridgeway State CourtsBOT5/10/2022, 7:07:33 PM
Case Action
Action
Member Added
Member
OfficerVideoGame (ovg#8791)
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:07:37 PM
Public Defender ^
Avatar
Ridgeway State CourtsBOT5/10/2022, 7:07:53 PM
Case Action
Action
Member Added
Member
MatthewSandringham (a carlyle#0924)
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:08:05 PM
Please send the criminal information here. @a carlyle
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:08:08 PM
let the record show that i was unable to find or locate a discord account for the defendant
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:08:56 PM
Alright. If the criminal information is accepted and a summons is issued, I will have the Sheriff's Office attempt to contact the defendant.
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:09:04 PM
If they are unsuccessful, we will proceed in absentia.
Avatar
a carlyle5/10/2022, 7:10:44 PM
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xJO1JVGlfBSQ4hmvJKsGsclfR5qvm4/view Criminal Information, Your Honor. Please note investigators were also unable to contact the defendant, presumably not in any discords. @zac2524

cc: @ovg
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:14:32 PM
thank you for the speedy CI
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:17:01 PM
Thank you.
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:17:56 PM
Probable cause has been established.
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:18:03 PM
I will now draw up a summons.
Avatar
a carlyle5/10/2022, 7:18:18 PM
Thank you, Your Honor.
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:37:39 PM
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EfkFNLCA3ewVw3f9QMYqKFY0J64HLw6l/view?usp=sharing motion for discovery, @zac2524

cc: @a carlyle
Google Drive is a free way to keep your files backed up and easy to reach from any phone, tablet, or computer. Start with 15GB of Google storage – free.
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:41:16 PM
I usually just open discovery sua sponte but let's wait for the Sheriff's Office to attempt making contact with the Defendant.
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:41:23 PM
Once that is fully established, we can move to discovery.
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:42:10 PM
gotchas
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:42:21 PM
we just filing everything fast today in this case
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:42:32 PM
maybe a tad too fast
Avatar
zac25245/10/2022, 7:42:43 PM
Way better than being too slow
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:42:49 PM
agreed
Avatar
ovg5/10/2022, 7:42:54 PM
might aswell give u everything
Avatar
zac25245/11/2022, 8:03:45 PM
The Sheriff's Office could not make contact with the defendant. We will therefore proceed in absentia. The court enters an automatic plea of not-guilty.
Avatar
zac25245/11/2022, 8:03:55 PM
Your motion for discovery has been accepted. Discovery will be open until May 14, 2022 at 9:00 PM EST and the State will be responsible for disclosing evidence with respect to the discovery motion. @ovg
Avatar
zac25245/11/2022, 8:04:01 PM
@a carlyle
Avatar
a carlyle5/12/2022, 2:36:58 AM
https://drive.google.com/file/d/19Bune_-7bIjPPiXwB3yikTuzqR2bo-NU/view?usp=sharing @zac2524
Cc: @ovg
Avatar
a carlyle5/12/2022, 11:58:45 AM
Note to the court: I won't be around from 1700 BST 13/05/22 until around 1900 BST 15/05/22 @zac2524 - applies to all cases I'm involved in.
Avatar
ovg5/12/2022, 6:43:26 PM
discovery acknowledged
Avatar
ovg5/12/2022, 6:43:29 PM
thank you
Avatar
ovg5/12/2022, 11:20:10 PM
defense has no objection to evidence
Avatar
ovg5/12/2022, 11:20:20 PM
ready to proceed with scheduling trial
Avatar
zac25245/14/2022, 10:25:35 AM
Wonderful.
Avatar
zac25245/14/2022, 10:25:49 AM
Anything you wish to address before we begin scheduling for trial? @a carlyle
Avatar
a carlyle5/15/2022, 9:18:32 AM
No concerns your honor. I shall be back shortly so will be able to begin with scheduling trial.

@zac2524
Avatar
zac25245/16/2022, 5:22:36 PM
Alright.
Avatar
a carlyle5/17/2022, 4:47:18 PM
Any suggestions for dates and times for trial??
Avatar
zac25245/17/2022, 9:12:34 PM
Possibly some time Friday afternoon.
Avatar
ovg5/17/2022, 11:16:03 PM
graduating this week so i’d love to be able to push it back a bit
Avatar
a carlyle5/18/2022, 7:20:27 AM
I can do this weekend as long as its BST friendly, can do monday or tuesday as well
Avatar
a carlyle5/18/2022, 7:40:08 AM
Ideally this weekend would be best if we can get through the entire trial, since I go away the weekend after
Avatar
zac25245/18/2022, 8:37:45 AM
Ok, we can aim for the weekend.
Avatar
ovg5/18/2022, 4:16:43 PM
doubt i’ll be free this weekend plenty of grad parties
Avatar
ovg5/18/2022, 4:16:51 PM
but i’ll be free all weekday after sunday
Avatar
a carlyle5/18/2022, 4:18:09 PM
Monday 6PM?
Avatar
a carlyle5/18/2022, 4:18:11 PM
EST
Avatar
a carlyle5/18/2022, 4:18:42 PM
if we can agree to then that'd work
Avatar
ovg5/18/2022, 4:53:49 PM
money
Avatar
ovg5/18/2022, 4:53:51 PM
that works
Avatar
zac25245/18/2022, 5:28:28 PM
That should work I believe.
Avatar ovg
defense has no objection to evidence...
Avatar
ovg5/21/2022, 1:41:56 PM
after seeing the courts ruling in #state-of-ridgeway-v-infinityturtlexd i'd like to submit a motion to strike exhibit b. will the court still entertain those motions at this time? @zac2524 (just asking now so i dont waste time filing paperwork only to be hit with a "ur not allowed u said no objections,")
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 1:43:35 PM
I'll allow it but it is very close to trial. I probably won't allow it again.
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 1:43:50 PM
I'll accept an oral motion if you don't want to file paperwork.
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 1:44:03 PM
I'll also give the State ample time to respond and amend their evidence if needed.
Avatar
ovg5/21/2022, 1:46:02 PM
Thank you, your honor, your generosity and flexibility is much appreciated.
Avatar
ovg5/21/2022, 1:53:40 PM
The defense moves the strike Exhibit B of the prosecutions discovery, on the grounds that the government failed to authenticate the evidence. Exhibits from Discord are admissible evidence, so long as the submitting party “authenticate[s] identities through a client reload and display of Discord ID.” See Rid. R. Evid. 55(d). Neither the reload nor a display of Discord ID is shown in Exhibit B, thus violating the Ridgeway Rules of Evidence, and making it inadmissible in a court of law. By rule, Discord evidence must be authenticated before trial, not during trial, as was ruled in State of Ridgeway v. InfinityTurtleXD. If the evidence isn't authenticated, how can we confirm that it's really the complainant speaking, instead of inspect element? Discord evidence is quite easy to fake, which is the purpose of the authenticating rule, it's to ensure only real evidence gets admitted into court. This rule is one of the most important and practical rules in the rules of evidence, and it must be respected.

Therefore, the Court should accept this motion to strike Exhibit B submitted by the Government.
Avatar
ovg5/21/2022, 1:53:45 PM
cc: @a carlyle
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 1:58:16 PM
@a carlyle Please produce a response by May 23, 2022 at 3:00 PM EST. This might end up cutting into the trial time, so please try to get your response in before then so that I can rule on it promptly. We may need to push back the trial but we can determine if we need to once we get closer to Monday.
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 2:01:39 PM
Will an oral response suffice, Your Honor?
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 2:05:15 PM
@zac2524
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 2:17:55 PM
Yes, it will. @a carlyle
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 2:31:33 PM
Your Honour, The defense has claimed that Exhibit B, as disclosed by the State, is inadmissible as per the Ridgeway Rules of Evidence due to its lack of authentication. The defense states that the Exhibit could be edited through "inspect element", however, the State believes it is abundantly clear that this evidence is untouched by the State, and that no employee of the State would risk their employment, or reputation to have someone convicted of a crime. Additionally, given the fact the evidence is being recorded on the discord app, it makes it impossible to change any comment through "inspect element", and only the user who wrote the message can edit their messages.

As per Rid. R. Evid. 54 (b) (1) & (2), the State can authenticate evidence through Testimony of a witness with knowledge of what has been said, or through non-expert opinion about handwriting. The State can authenticate the evidence the Defense wishes to strike through both of these means.

As such this motion should be denied.

@zac2524
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 2:33:55 PM
The motion to strike exhibit B is conditionally granted. If the State is able to produce a version of exhibit B which includes the Discord IDs of those involved in the conversation as well as a reload of the Discord client, then I will allow it to be resubmitted into evidence. If this is genuinely not possible, I will leave exhibit B in evidence and allow for it to be authenticated during trial. This exception is being made due to how close we are to trial. @a carlyle @ovg
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 2:38:18 PM
Very well Your Honor. I should be able to attain a new version of Exhibit B with the stated requisites by tonight.
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 2:48:19 PM
Sounds good, thank you.
Avatar
ovg5/21/2022, 3:07:14 PM
Thank you your Honor. Defense again apologizes for late motion and will be ok with delaying if we need to
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 3:08:51 PM
There should be no delay on trial hopefully.
Avatar
a carlyle5/21/2022, 8:23:52 PM
Update to the States Exhibit B: https://youtu.be/TPFjNjtMAN0

@zac2524 @ovg
Avatar
zac25245/21/2022, 8:24:43 PM
Perfect, thank you.
Avatar
zac25245/22/2022, 3:39:02 PM
If nothing changes tomorrow, we can get started at 6:00 PM EST.
Avatar
a carlyle5/22/2022, 3:42:43 PM
Fantastic, Ive asked both of my witness, they said they should be available. So if we're lucky we might get through a lot of the trial
Avatar
zac25245/22/2022, 3:58:28 PM
Sounds good.
Avatar
zac25245/23/2022, 4:07:02 PM
Would it be possible to push this to around 6:30 PM EST? If not, I may still be able to do 6:00 PM EST. @ovg @a carlyle
Avatar
a carlyle5/23/2022, 4:07:25 PM
No objections
Avatar
ovg5/23/2022, 4:48:14 PM
no objections
Avatar
a carlyle5/23/2022, 6:24:08 PM
Server 1? @zac2524 @ovg
Avatar
zac25245/23/2022, 6:24:31 PM
Yes, I’ll be there momentarily
Avatar
ovg5/23/2022, 6:29:39 PM
word
Avatar
zac25245/23/2022, 7:49:40 PM
We can return in around 10 minutes.
Avatar
zac25245/24/2022, 10:14:22 AM
In-game proceedings have been completed and a verdict will be rendered soon.
Avatar
Ridgeway State CourtsBOT5/25/2022, 6:21:50 PM
Case Action
Action
Case Unsealed
Executor
zac2524
Avatar
zac25245/28/2022, 5:36:09 PM
@ovg @a carlyle As I have been confirmed to the Supreme Court, I am no longer allowed to preside over this case. I planned to release the verdict later today but I will provide the new Judge with my suggestions which they are free to accept or reject.
Avatar
shitterowner5/28/2022, 5:50:31 PM
All cases zac has had have been transferred to mytrius.
Avatar
Maison5/28/2022, 7:52:30 PM
ok
Avatar
Maison5/28/2022, 10:18:19 PM
has the defendant been arraigned?
Avatar
ovg5/29/2022, 3:41:15 AM
the entire trial has been conducted
Avatar
ovg5/29/2022, 3:41:28 AM
defendant was in abstentia
Avatar
Maison5/29/2022, 4:34:06 AM
oh boy
Avatar
Maison5/29/2022, 4:34:12 AM
@zac2524 could you fill me in
Avatar
zac25245/29/2022, 1:04:21 PM
Yes, I'll DM you
Avatar
Maison5/29/2022, 2:37:25 PM
I’ll review the trial and make a ruling tonight
Avatar
Maison5/30/2022, 12:16:09 AM
ruling expected tomorrow
Avatar
Maison5/30/2022, 10:15:40 PM
writing the ruling now
Avatar
Maison5/30/2022, 10:27:58 PM
apologies the ruling isn't as detailed as I'd like it to be but going off of a video is a little tough.
Avatar
Ridgeway State CourtsBOT5/30/2022, 10:28:55 PM
Case Action
Action
Ruling Entered
Executor
Mytrius
Link
Avatar
Maison5/30/2022, 10:29:32 PM
oh boy
Avatar
ovg5/30/2022, 11:19:48 PM
Thank you, your honor.